Stony Sub

Discover delicious sandwiches at Stony Sub in Chicago! Enjoy our famous chicken wings, Italian beef, gyros, steak sandwiches, and more. Cash only. Visit us at 8440 S Stony Island Ave today!

Welcome to Stony Sub

Experience the finest dining

Stony Sub
Stony Sub
Stony Sub
Stony Sub

Stony Sub Sandwich Shop, located at 8440 S Stony Island Ave in Chicago, offers an inviting atmosphere for sandwich lovers. This cash-only establishment greets you with a bustling vibe, especially on weekends. Known for its diverse menu, Stony Sub serves a wide selection of sandwiches, including the famous gym shoe sandwich and juicy Italian beef. The shop draws patrons from the surrounding neighborhoods, making it a cherished local spot. Reviews highlight the crispy chicken wings, savory gyros, and unforgettable mild sauce that many crave. Whether it’s a late-night treat or a quick lunch, Stony Sub stands out as a go-to choice for satisfying cravings.

Stony Sub boasts an extensive menu with 93 flavorful options, catering to all types of diners. They offer classic subs, including roast beef and corned beef, alongside unique items like their steak burritos and pizza puffs. Vegetarians will also find satisfying choices, such as their hearty salads and veggie sandwiches. Don’t overlook the side orders, especially the crispy cheese sticks and generous fries. The shop operates with a cash-only policy, ensuring a smooth transaction.

Regulars appreciate the prompt service during rush hours, particularly on Saturdays when the shop reaches full capacity. Overall, the range of flavors and styles keeps the community coming back for more.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

8440 S Stony Island Ave, Chicago, IL 60617, United States

Phone

+1 773-978-4000

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

Stony Sub
Stony Sub
Stony Sub
Stony Sub

Stony Sub takes pride in its rich history and commitment to serving quality food. It has become an institution in the Chicago area, cherished not just for its food but also for its welcoming environment. Diners appreciate how well the staff knows frequent customers, making every visit feel personal. The menu features a mix of American and Mediterranean influences, making it a melting pot of flavors.

Each dish is crafted to meet the cravings of diverse patrons, ensuring there is something for everyone. Saturday nights often see packed tables, with many opting to enjoy a meal after a night out. Thanks to its attentive staff and quality ingredients, Stony Sub creates an experience that is not just about food but community connection as well.

Local favorites include the steak sandwiches and the popular chicken wings, which receive rave reviews for their taste and texture.

The mild sauce served with many dishes has garnered a dedicated following, with customers often asking for extra servings to enhance their meals. Guests stop by for lunch and dinner throughout the week, especially during peak hours, maintaining a steady stream of happy diners. Visitors typically find a mix of locals, students, and families, each enjoying their own meal within the same vibrant space.

This sense of community makes Stony Sub more than just a sandwich shop; it’s a gathering place where connections are made over good food. As seasons change, the menu adapts slightly to include seasonal specials, respecting the local palate and keeping the experience fresh. Stony Sub embodies the spirit of Chicago—diverse, flavorful, and always welcoming.

Stony Sub

The exterior of Stony Sub hints at the casual dining experience within. Its modest signage and inviting entrance draw in a diverse crowd, from hungry locals to late-night adventurers. The outdoor seating area, often bustling with laughter and conversation, fosters a friendly vibe. Patrons enjoy their meals outside during warmer months, soaking in the vibrant energy of the neighborhood. At night, the warm lights create an inviting atmosphere that captivates passersby. Stony Sub is more than just a spot to eat; it’s a local landmark that feels like home.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • SundayOpen 24 hours
  • MondayOpen 24 hours
  • TuesdayOpen 24 hours
  • WednesdayOpen 24 hours
  • ThursdayOpen 24 hours
  • FridayOpen 24 hours
  • SaturdayOpen 24 hours

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

For fans of a messy, delicious sandwich, their famous Jim Shoe sandwich would satisfy. This sandwich was loaded with meat and flavors, making it hard to finish without any parts falling out. The food came out quickly, and the place is cash-only.

Z
Zhi D.

It's always a good time at Stony Sub...got the 2nd best thing there today, wings! But that Gym Shoe was calling my name

M
Mark D.

Food...well it is what it is, and if you know...well you know. Open 24/7, breakfast, hangover or whatever. It gets you right. Be careful at night if there isn't any traffic.

J
Jory S.

40 years of my life were wasted not having a Jim Shoe! This was life changing it has the sweet savory meats with the hot heat of the peppers and giardiniera. The Perfect arrangement for a sandwich.

J
Jason S.

Stony Sub is a good spot for a quick and filling meal. Their sandwiches are big, tasty, and reasonably priced, with plenty of options to choose from. Service is usually fast, though the place can feel a bit crowded at times. A solid choice if you're in the area and want something satisfying.

G
Gmtredn N.

This place is great first of all because it's 24 hours! It's always clean in the lobby(even with the winter weather ) The Italian Beef and the Jim Shoo is delicious and tasty, the portions are very generous every single time!

D
D C.